• Photos
  • Bio
  • Contact Ian

Ian Sidden

Subscribe

  • Email
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • Craft
  • My News
  • About the Music
  • The Rest of Life

Rules-Based Singing

December 16, 2017 By Ian Sidden

Since we can’t fully hear ourselves, and since we might decide we can take excessive vocal risk based on transitory feelings, we have to have a process that includes certain rules. We then rely on these rules to guide us through challenging situations where our present emotions might encourage us to behave differently:

  • “I breathe here. No matter what.”
  • “I round my lips here. No matter what.”
  • “I wear my ear plugs for this piece. No matter what.”
  • “I only give 85% of my max volume here even though it says ff. No matter what.”
  • “I maintain some squillo here, even though it says ppp. No matter what.”
  • “I modify the vowel here. No matter what.”
  • “I check in with the conductor here. No matter what.”

You’ll develop these rules on your own given your own strengths and weaknesses and the challenges of your given circumstances. When should you make such rules? Here are a few over arching times:

  • When you keep forgetting something that you know will help you.
  • When you have shifting circumstances such as room acoustics.
  • When you have very difficult music, especially music that presents a risk of early vocal fatigue.

Behind all this is the idea that your practice is mindful, so that you can develop rules in advance in order to fully integrate them. But late-developed rules are better than none at all.

Filed Under: Craft Tagged With: Learning Music, mindfulness, practice, risk, rules

Learning Music

March 17, 2009 By Ian Sidden

Personally, when I first began taking lessons, I had no idea how to go about learning music. This made singing and performing very stressful. I now have a technique for learning music that has made singing much more fun. The advice offered here is not meant to be exhaustive. It does not include techniques such as coloratura learning techniques, or diction learning techniques, but I do hope that it may serve to be a starting point for learning how to learn. wittner_metronome

Preparation for Learning Music

Some questions to think over before you begin working on your new song:

  1. Do you like the song?
  2. What is the theme of the song? How does the composer handle this?
  3. Who is singing it? Is the character someone you could perform credibly?
  4. Do you have the technical abilities to sing this piece? Can you learn those abilities in time to perform it?
  5. If applicable, does your accompanist have the technical abilities to play this piece?
  6. How much time do you have? Decide if it is reasonable to learn your piece in certain amounts of time. For example, I had to learn “Eilt! Ihr angefochnen Seelen” from Bach’s St. John Passion. It took me months of work to feel confident on it. If I only had a week to learn it, then that would have not worked.
  7. Translate the piece if it is in a foreign language. It is really best to know what you are saying while you are learning the piece.

Hierarchical Approach

I believe a hierarchical approach is appropriate for most cases. A singer’s part as a whole is a large number of smaller pieces that can and should be broken down into smaller more easily digestible chunks. From there, each chunk should be approached individually and then added to one another in a methodical way.

The first step is to break the piece apart into small sections. Oftentimes, the period between two breaths will suffice, though you may want to work larger sections. Begin with the spots that will give you the most trouble such as patter or coloratura sections or other rhythmically challenging or diction-ally challenging parts. If the melody is difficult because of technical limitations, then save that until after the rhythm, words, and notes are learned. This should be discussed with your teacher when first coaching your song.

Second, work each section according to a hierarchy. My hierarchy goes like this, which is similar to that found in The Art of the Song Recital by Shirlee Emmons and Stanly Sonntag:

  • Rhythm

I read somewhere a long time ago that there are only 12 notes to play but there are infinite rhythms. I like this idea because losing one’s pitch center for a moment cannot usually stop a performance in its tracks, but losing one’s rhythm certainly can. So, the singer should, without melody or words, chant the rhythm to a metronome on some nonsense syllable (‘la’ ‘da’ ‘bi’ or something like that). Each word syllable should get its own nonsense syllable. The singer should begin slowly and work up to above concert tempo. At concert tempo, breaths should be decided, written into the score, and should be practiced in time.

  • Words

The words should be practiced on their own first so that any diction difficulties are dealt with before ever being applied to music.

  • Words and rhythm

Now, with a metronome, the singer chants the words in time and observes breath signs and other musical notation. Again, the singer should begin slowly and work his/her way up beyond concert tempo.

  • Melody

The melody is then isolated outside of time and learned. It should not be sung in any dramatic sense. Instead just get the notes into your ear well enough that you can reproduce them.

  • Melody and rhythm

The melody and rhythm are sung on nonsense syllables first slowly then quicker and quicker.

  • Melody, rhythm and words

Now all the pieces are put together slowly at first, then working towards a higher tempo.

(Note: Some people suggest different hierarchies (such as working on the words first), and that is just fine by me. I believe that rhythm should go first because it is usually the hardest part of a piece. However, if a piece has a different set of challenges, then you might want to rearrange how you approach it.)

My personal criteria for deciding whether or not I have a section learned well is if I can successfully sing it in rhythm with good diction and pitch center without my accompanist. Only then do I feel very comfortable working with my accompanist on a song.

Be Patient

Be patient with yourself because this process is foolproof if you actually follow it. You will  save time because you will not learn bad habits in the process of learning your music. You will also feel much more comfortable singing in front of people by learning your songs so accurately.

Filed Under: Craft Tagged With: Learning Music, Practicing, Preparation

About Ian

Ian Sidden is currently a baritone member of the Theater Dortmund Opera chorus. Read More…

Latest Posts

Premiere: La muette de Portici

Tonight at Theater Dortmund, we’re having our premiere of Auber’s La muette de Portici. However, it will be a closed performance.

The Stress Feedback Loop

Anything can turn into a habit if we practice it enough, and we walk around with habitual physical stress making us feel and sound stressed.

“Im weißen Rössl” Morning After

Last night, we had the premiere of “Im weißen Rössl” at Theater Dortmund. I don’t think I’ve ever heard our audience laugh as hard or as consistently as they did last night. The creative combination of the cast and Regie team has really made magic here. For my part, I enjoy singing the tunes, and […]

Solving Problems

One lens to view your task as a performer is as a problem solver.

Premiere: Madama Butterfly

Tonight is our premiere of Madama Butterfly in Opernhaus Dortmund. I’m playing Cio-Cio-San’s Uncle Yakusidé, and I’m very excited to be a part of this production.

Copyright © 2021 · WordPress